Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Yes, Australian businesses have become less dynamic. But there are bigger reasons for our sliding productivity growth

  • Written by: Stephen King, Professor, Monash University
Yes, Australian businesses have become less dynamic. But there are bigger reasons for our sliding productivity growth

Since 2005, annual labour productivity growth (growth in output per hour worked) has been the best part of one percentage point below its long-term average in Australia and other developed countries.

The Productivity Inquiry[1] that I helped conduct for the Productivity Commission found this will lead to much-slower improvements in Australians’ living standards than in the past.

In the search for a culprit, economists including Australia’s Competition Minister Andrew Leigh[2] have pointed to reduced business competition resulting in decreasing dynamism, by which they mean:

  • less entry and exit[3] of firms
  • less job-switching
  • a significant reduction in business investment
  • mergers leading to increased business concentration
  • an increase in the markups businesses can sustain
  • only few highly-productive firms, with the rest increasingly less so

A study that I have just published in Australian Economic Papers[4], reviews the evidence and finds that while most of these things have happened (and while many are undesirable) they aren’t sufficient to explain what’s happened to productivity.

The findings suggest that even if we did make our economy more competitive and businesses more dynamic (and we probably should) improving productivity growth depends on a much bigger set of policy reforms.

Here’s what we find.

Firm entry and exit has been slowing

In Australia, the rates of firm entry and exit (meaning companies either joining or dropping out of an industry) declined[5] between 2005–06 and 2012–13.

While there’s been an increase in firm entry more recently, it’s been mainly among non-employing business – sole traders and independent contractors – rather than bigger businesses.

In the US (we don’t have an equivalent Australian study) red tape may be strangling dynamism. Investment in new profitable businesses has slowed at the same time as there has been a significant increase in regulation of those businesses.

In Australia, improvements in business survival rates at least partly seem to reflect improved conditions for both survivors and new entrants, rather than barriers that protect unproductive survivors at the expense of more-productive entrants.

Job-switching has slowed

Australian job mobility has declined dramatically[6] over the past 30  years, in part because the population is ageing, and older workers are less likely to switch jobs than younger workers.

Another explanation might be that Australian businesses face a less volatile environment, suggesting job turnover does not have value in its own right.

While job churn tends to fall if barriers to job mobility rise, it also falls when businesses face fewer shocks, making any link between declining job turnover and diminished competition ambiguous.

Business investment has slowed

Non-mining business investment in Australia has stagnated over recent decades, as it has in a number of other advanced economies.

Among the suggested explanations are risk aversion and uncertainty, pessimism about the future and lower productivity growth. The role, played by competition – if any – is far from clear.

Business concentration has climbed

The average concentration of Australian businesses (the extent to which industries are dominated by a few big firms) appears to have been falling until the early 2000s, and climbing[7] since then.

Most of the increased concentration appears to have been in already-concentrated industries, with technological advances and exposure to imports explaining a lot of it.

As an example, concentration has increased in “warehousing and storage”, but the industry has taken advantage of technological advances[8] including parcel tracking and smart warehouses, meaning both concentration and competition have increased as firms have scaled up to install new technologies.

Businesses profit margins have climbed

Markups (profit margins) appear to have climbed by around 57% in Australia between 1980 to 2016, which is less than in the US, Canada and much of the European Union, but greater than in New Zealand and most Asian countries except for South Korea.

But markups at the level of the firm are difficult to measure because they depend on assumptions about the way the firm makes its products. Different assumptions can produce very different estimates.

There are only a few highly-productive firms

Globally and in Australia the most-productive firms seem to be three to four times more productive than the less productive, but, at least in Australia, there is little evidence to suggest the gap is widening.

What evidence there is suggests the gap between the most-productive Australian firms and the most-productive global firms is widening[9], suggesting all Australian firms are slower to adopt leading technologies than they were.

Put bluntly, Australian businesses as a whole appear to have become slow to adopt world best practice; which is a problem, but not necessarily a problem of highly-productive firms versus the rest.

There are a range of policies[10] that can help to reverse the decline, but it is far from clear that competition plays much of a role.

We’re at risk of chasing the wrong target

The broader reasons for Australia’s declining productivity growth include changing demographics, changing international trade patterns and the changing nature of industries as Australia continues to moves towards a more service-based economy.

Productivity Commission[11] Fixing our productivity problem requires a suite of changes that address these and other issues. In March, the Productivity Commission laid out a roadmap[12]. Of course, we shouldn’t ignore competition. The government’s 2015 Competition Policy Review[13] focused on updating competition and consumer laws. Many of its recommendations remain on the shelf. Further, new challenges are emerging. To pick one, Australia currently has three alternative ways to get competition clearances when businesses merge. Unsurprisingly, they pick the path of least resistance. The head of the Competition and Consumer Commission Gina Cass-Gottlieb has developed a proposal[14] that would help. Actually boosting productivity will require measures that cover education, technology, business regulation, taxation, carbon emissions, and more. Blaming declining dynamism and declining competition for declining productivity is not just a diversion, it risks making us do the wrong things. References^ Productivity Inquiry (www.pc.gov.au)^ Andrew Leigh (ministers.treasury.gov.au)^ entry and exit (blogs.worldbank.org)^ Australian Economic Papers (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^ declined (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^ declined dramatically (www.pc.gov.au)^ climbing (treasury.gov.au)^ technological advances (www.pc.gov.au)^ widening (read.oecd-ilibrary.org)^ range of policies (www.pc.gov.au)^ Productivity Commission (www.pc.gov.au)^ roadmap (www.pc.gov.au)^ Competition Policy Review (treasury.gov.au)^ developed a proposal (www.accc.gov.au)Authors: Stephen King, Professor, Monash University

Read more https://theconversation.com/yes-australian-businesses-have-become-less-dynamic-but-there-are-bigger-reasons-for-our-sliding-productivity-growth-207327

The Weekend Times Magazine

The Most Popular Tattoo Placements (and Why)

Choosing where to place your tattoo is almost as important as choosing the artwork itself. Placement affects how a tattoo looks, how it heals, how visible it is in day-to-day...

Could You Furnish and Equip a Whole House with IKEA Products?

IKEA has long been known as the global giant of affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. From minimalist Scandinavian sofas to clever kitchen gadgets, the Swedish retailer has built its reputation on making...

Why Sydney Never Stops Welcoming the World

Every weekend, Australia's harbour city reminds us why international tourism matters. Walk through Circular Quay on a Saturday morning and you'll hear dozens of languages before you've finished your coffee. Families photograph...

The Future of the Sales Handoff: From AI SDR to Human Closer

Artificial intelligence is altering the sales process at lightning speed. For many firms, AI is their Sales Development Representative. This class of SDRs completes the initial stage of the sales...

Sydney Residents: Options for a Weekend Away Short Break

Living in Sydney offers an enviable lifestyle, but even the most iconic city in Australia can feel hectic at times. Whether it’s the daily commute, a fast-paced work schedule, or...

Australian holiday deals from Accor

For travellers looking to escape their cabin fever and embark on a holiday closer to home, Accor has released a range of state-by-state accommodation deals.   If you’re yearning for a change...

Making these five clever moving mistakes will cost you both money and time

Moving to a new location can be a thrilling adventure, but it can also be costly and stressful. Because so much packing, planning, and logistics are involved, it is easy...

How Pest Control Albury Protects Homes And Businesses From Harmful Pests

Residents and business owners in regional New South Wales understand the challenges that seasonal pests can bring. Many turn to Pest Control Albury to keep their properties safe, hygienic and free...

Why Probiotics for Dogs Are Important for Digestive and Overall Health

Maintaining a healthy digestive system is essential for a dog's wellbeing, and probiotics for dogs have become increasingly popular among pet owners looking to support their pet’s health naturally. The digestive...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat