Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

How a secret plan 50 years ago changed Australia's economy forever, in just one night

  • Written by: Alex Millmow, Senior Fellow, Federation University Australia
How a secret plan 50 years ago changed Australia's economy forever, in just one night

At a time when governments are timid, keener to announce reviews[1] than decisions, it’s refreshing to remember what happened 50 years ago today – on July 18 1973.

Inflation had surged to 14%[2]. Australia’s biggest customer, the United Kingdom, had joined the European Economic Community[3], agreeing to buy products from it rather than Australia. And the newly formed Organisation of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries had doubled[4] the price of oil.

The tariffs imposed on imported goods to protect Australian manufacturers from competition were extraordinarily high. For clothing, they reached 55%[5]; for motor vehicles, 45%[6].

Then, with absolutely no public indication he had been considering anything as drastic, at 7pm on Wednesday July 18, the recently elected prime minister Gough Whitlam made an announcement[7].

Every tariff cut by one quarter overnight

From midnight, all tariffs would be cut by 25%. As Whitlam put it: “each tariff will be reduced by one quarter of what it is now”.

Gough Whitlam's statement[8] If Australian businesses (and the Australian public) were caught by surprise, it was because Whitlam had planned the whole thing in secret. He had given a six-person committee just three weeks to work out the details. Although the committee was chaired by the head of the Tariff Board, Alf Rattigan, and included an official from Whitlam’s own department, the department of industry and the department of trade, it met in an obscure location in Canberra’s civic centre rather than in public service offices, where the project might be discovered. Not included in the committee was a representative of the treasury, which its then deputy head John Stone said “knew nothing[9]” about what was unfolding. But driving the work of the committee were two academic outsiders – Fred Gruen, an economics professor at the Australian National University and adviser to Whitlam, and Brian Brogan, an economics lecturer at Monash University who was advising the trade minister, Jim Cairns. Outsiders, not treasury insiders As economists rather than bureaucrats, Gruen and Brogan were able to see benefits where others saw entrenched interests. Going to the tariff board and asking for extra tariffs, whenever it looked as if your prices might be undercut by imports, had become a reflex action for Australian businesses. In the words of Gary Banks[10] – later to become head of the successor to the tariff board, the Productivity Commission: “it was not a shameful thing for a conga line of industrialists to be seen wending its way to Canberra”. Read more: Half a century on, it's time to reassess the Whitlam government's economic legacy[11] Tariffs were good for business owners, athough bad for their customers, who had to pay much higher prices and often got worse goods[12]. They were also good for government – bringing in tax revenue. Whitlam was more interested in bringing down inflation. His announcement said increased competition would have a salutary effect upon those who have taken advantage of shortages by unjustified price increases which have exploited the public. Any firm seriously hurt by the extra imports could apply to a newly established tribunal for assistance, but the tribunal should not provide relief as a matter of course – that is, simply because the question of relief had been referred to it. So Whitlam offered “rationalisation assistance” to encourage firms to refocus their operations, and “compensation for closure” where that couldn’t be done and production had to cease. For displaced workers, the 7pm announcement offered anyone who lost their job retraining, as well as a weekly amount equal to his [sic] average wage in the previous six months until he obtains or is found suitable alternative employment. Over the next seven years, manufacturing employment fell by 80,000[13], but few of those job losses were immediate. Fifteen months after the 25% tariff cut, fewer than 6,000[14] people had claimed the wage replacement offered on the night of the announcement. When Whitlam went to the polls a year after the cut in the double dissolution election of May 1974, 122 university economists signed an open letter[15] of support. The letter said the general thrust of the government’s policy responses had been in the best interests of the nation as a whole, and added, more importantly, we seriously doubt that the previous government would have had the wisdom or the courage to undertake it. It had certainly given no indication of moving in that direction while it was in power, even though the need for such policies had become obvious. In its later days in office, the Whitlam government was roundly criticised for its irresponsible public spending. Ironically, in its approach to tariffs in the 1970s, it had taken the first steps in a neoliberal direction that characterised western governments of the 1980s. By acting boldly after decades of inaction, Whitlam showed what a government could do. It was a lesson his Labor successor Bob Hawke took to heart a decade later, when he floated the dollar, revamped Australia’s tax system and put in place a series of further cuts that reduced tariffs to near zero. It’s something we see less of today.

References

  1. ^ reviews (www.pc.gov.au)
  2. ^ 14% (www.datawrapper.de)
  3. ^ European Economic Community (news.bbc.co.uk)
  4. ^ doubled (advisor.visualcapitalist.com)
  5. ^ 55% (www.pc.gov.au)
  6. ^ 45% (ro.uow.edu.au)
  7. ^ announcement (pmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au)
  8. ^ Gough Whitlam's statement (pmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au)
  9. ^ knew nothing (cdn.theconversation.com)
  10. ^ Gary Banks (esavic.org.au)
  11. ^ Half a century on, it's time to reassess the Whitlam government's economic legacy (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ worse goods (www.afr.com)
  13. ^ 80,000 (www.bitre.gov.au)
  14. ^ 6,000 (www.jstor.org)
  15. ^ open letter (pmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au)

Authors: Alex Millmow, Senior Fellow, Federation University Australia

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-a-secret-plan-50-years-ago-changed-australias-economy-forever-in-just-one-night-209378

Find Out More. Get in Touch with The Times.

 Whether you have a question, a news tip, a business enquiry or would like more information, we're here to help

Please complete the enquiry form and a member of The Times team will respond as soon as possible.

Product enquiries

News Tips

Advertising & Sponsorship

Business Enquiries

Editorial Feedback

Corrections

Media Requests

Partnership Opportunities.

Email us at editor@TheTimes.com.au or use our enquiry form.

The Weekend Times Magazine

Creating a Custom Bathroom Vanity: Plan for These Things

Doing a bathroom reno and think a custom bathroom vanity could be just the thing? A custom vanity can completely transform the look and feel of a bathroom, from a...

Prime Minister interview with Karl Stefanovic and Alison Langdon, Today

KARL STEFANOVIC: Joining us now from Kirribilli House in Sydney. PM, good morning to you. Thank you for your time.    PRIME MINISTER: G’day Karl.   STEFANOVIC: The Premiers don't seem to be listening...

Should I get a COVID vaccine while I’m pregnant or breastfeeding?

From Monday, Australia’s front-line health workers, quarantine staff, border control officers, and workers and residents in aged-care homes will be offered the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. Some of these workers will be...

Why Sydney Never Stops Welcoming the World

Every weekend, Australia's harbour city reminds us why international tourism matters. Walk through Circular Quay on a Saturday morning and you'll hear dozens of languages before you've finished your coffee. Families photograph...

Smart Lock: The Future of Home Security and Convenience

A smart lock has revolutionized the way people think about home security. Moving beyond traditional keys and mechanical locks, smart locks bring technology and convenience together, offering homeowners and businesses a new...

Science Tutoring and Building Strong Foundations for Academic Success

For students tackling complex scientific concepts, science tutoring provides essential support that turns confusion into clarity. Science subjects demand more than memorisation. They require logical thinking, problem-solving skills, and the ability...

How To Install PVC Shutters At Home

Homes are the best place for relaxing and refreshing after the hectic and tiring daily life routine. The home should be decorated so that it gives people a warm welcome...

Who Can Install A Private Power Pole?

Private power poles provide property owners with the freedom to choose where electricity will enter the building. It also offers protection from hazards associated with being directly connected to the...

Evaporative Cooling Cleaning Melbourne for Fresh Air and Reliable Cooling

Regular Evaporative Cooling Cleaning Melbourne is essential for maintaining clean air, consistent cooling performance, and the overall reliability of evaporative cooling systems. These systems are widely used across Melbourne due to...