Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Cash could be almost gone in Australia in a decade – but like cheques, who'll miss it?

  • Written by: Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
Cash could be almost gone in Australia in a decade – but like cheques, who'll miss it?

Late last year, the Reserve Bank gave 1,000 Australians diaries and asked them to record every payment they made over the course of a week. Of the 13,000 payments, only 17 were with cheques.

It’s been an astounding collapse. Back in 1980 at the start of the credit card era, 85%[1] of non-cash payments were made with cheques. Today it’s less than 0.1%[2].

Earlier this month, the government announced it was following New Zealand[3], Denmark, the Netherlands and others[4], closing our cheque system down by 2030[5].

Meanwhile, New Zealand is already on to the next thing. Having phased out cheques[6], it’s now looking at winding down the use of cash[7].

So how close is Australia now to becoming a cash-free nation?

The hidden costs of cheques and cash

Cheques are horrendously expensive to process. The average cost of everything that had to happen to process a cheque exceeds $5[8] per payment, mostly borne by banks.

But cash is expensive in its own way. The average cost of creating, sorting and trucking all those sheets of plastic and coins exceeds 50 cents[9] per payment, mostly passed on to banks and retailers, and it is soaring as the number of payments plummets.

As recently as 2007, the vast bulk of consumer payments – 69% – were in cash. By 2019 only 27% were in cash. By 2022, after two years of COVID, it was only 13%[10].

At this rate, it’s hard to be certain how long cash will last.

What made cheques so slow and costly

For those who’ve never had to write one, cheques are bank-issued pieces of paper on which the owner writes the name of the person they want the bank to pay and the amount. They they hand it to that person, who then hands it to their bank, which then tries to get the money from the payer’s bank.

Cheques used to be exchanged in bags. cottonbro/pexels[11]

Behind the scenes, until recently when the electronic transmission of digital images changed things, each bank would collect all the cheques that had been presented to its branches each day and sort them into bags, one for each originating bank.

Then, late at night, its “bag man” would travel to a nondescript city location with a bag for each bank, hand the correct one to each of the other bagmen, and be given bags in return, which the bagman would take back to the bank for signature checking.

When each bank worked out what it owed the other bank, they would usually discover the flows largely cancelled each other out, and then make net payments which would be reflected in the cheque-writer’s account, up to five business days later.

Always expensive, the cost per cheque grew and grew as the number of Australians paying with cheques dwindled to a fraction of what it had been.

How moving cash became a loss-making business

It’s the same sort of story with cash. Although we don’t often think about it, cash costs an awful lot to move, sort and restock.

Printing the notes still makes money – it costs about 32 cents to make each note, whether it’s worth $5 or $100, although making some coins now loses money[12].

The real expense is in moving notes and coins around, keeping them nearby and restocking banks and cash registers. Aside from payments the Reserve Bank makes to banks for returning damaged notes, the banks (and, through them, the retailers) are expected to pay for the lot.

Read more: The Mint and Note Printing Australia make billions for Australia – but it could be at risk[13]

Until recently that gave the two firms that dominate the business (Linfox Armaguard, and Prosegur, which owns Chubb Security) a pretty good deal.

Except that the volume of cash they’ve carried has dived 47%[14] over the past ten years, 30% of it during COVID.

Both firms say their money-moving arms are incurring “heavy financial losses” and that if they increase their prices much more, retailers might move even further away from cash[15], pushing their costs even higher.

Linfox Armaguard and Prosegur have been given permission to merge. Linfox

Last week, the Competition and Consumer Commission allowed them to merge[16] on the condition that they limit their price increases to the consumer index plus 7.5% per year. That increase is so steep as to suggest a death spiral[17]: the more they charge, the less retailers will use cash, the more they’ll have to charge.

The only way out, unless they can make really big efficiencies, or unless the decline in the use of cash stops, would be for the government to return to subsidising the use of cash. It’s hard to see how it could make the case to do that when there are cheaper emerging technologies.

Bank transfers cost a mere fraction[18] of using cash, and pretty soon we’ll be able to use them for everything, via things such as QR codes[19].

So when will cash go the way of cheques?

A previous federal government has already tried to eliminate the use of cash for transactions worth more than $10,000, as part of its attack on the black economy.

Announced in 2016 by the Turnbull Coalition government, the ban was due to come into force in 2019[20]. But, after delays, in 2020 the Morrison-led Coalition government backed down[21].

If Australia wants to ban cash (and ban it for small transactions too – cash is now used less than cards for transactions of all sizes[22]) the easiest solution might be simply to wait.

Cards are now the dominant means of exchanging money, and electronic transfers are growing from a small base.

Pure extrapolation would suggest cash has less than a decade to go, but it will probably hang around for longer as an (expensive, little-used) backup that maintains privacy.

Like cheques, cash will probably die gradually, then suddenly[23]. By the time it does, there will be few users left who care.

References

  1. ^ 85% (www.rba.gov.au)
  2. ^ 0.1% (www.rba.gov.au)
  3. ^ New Zealand (www.justice.govt.nz)
  4. ^ others (www.sbs.com.au)
  5. ^ 2030 (ministers.treasury.gov.au)
  6. ^ phased out cheques (www.stuff.co.nz)
  7. ^ cash (www.rbnz.govt.nz)
  8. ^ $5 (www.rba.gov.au)
  9. ^ 50 cents (www.rba.gov.au)
  10. ^ 13% (www.rba.gov.au)
  11. ^ cottonbro/pexels (www.pexels.com)
  12. ^ loses money (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ The Mint and Note Printing Australia make billions for Australia – but it could be at risk (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ 47% (www.accc.gov.au)
  15. ^ further away from cash (images.theconversation.com)
  16. ^ merge (www.accc.gov.au)
  17. ^ death spiral (www.energynetworks.com.au)
  18. ^ mere fraction (www.rba.gov.au)
  19. ^ QR codes (www.mobiletransaction.org)
  20. ^ 2019 (ministers.treasury.gov.au)
  21. ^ backed down (www.abc.net.au)
  22. ^ of all sizes (www.rba.gov.au)
  23. ^ gradually, then suddenly (quoteinvestigator.com)

Authors: Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Read more https://theconversation.com/cash-could-be-almost-gone-in-australia-in-a-decade-but-like-cheques-wholl-miss-it-208020

The Weekend Times Magazine

6 things that can go wrong if your iron isn't adequate before falling pregnant

Preconception care involves making sure you have adequate supply of all the nutrients essential to the health of the sperm and ova (egg) and to fetal development. Preconception also involves...

Aussies get budget savvy with surge in deferred payment of bills

Deferit co-founders Mat Blas and Jonty Hirsowitz Deferit, a payment platform exclusively focused on helping people pay their bills on time, has released new data on the huge uptake of its...

Why More Perth Homeowners Are Choosing Bidets for Modern Bathrooms

Bathroom renovations are no longer just about choosing stylish tiles, modern vanities and attractive tapware. Homeowners are increasingly considering how their bathrooms can support better hygiene, everyday comfort and long-term...

Does Sydney Australia Have a Good Nightlife Scene?

In the last several years, Sydney's nightlife has changed dramatically. The New South Wales state government adopted Draconian lockout regulations in 2014, forcing city center venues to close their doors...

Body Contouring Melbourne: Sculpting Confidence with Safe and Effective Treatments

Achieving your ideal body shape often takes more than just diet and exercise. For those looking to enhance their natural contours, body contouring Melbourne clinics offer advanced treatments designed to reduce...

Men’s style: where to buy it and how to build it

Most men are not taught style. They are taught how to work, drive, earn money and solve problems. Fashion and presentation are often treated as secondary concerns, something instinctive that men...

The Best Camera Smartphones for 2021

Everyone is a photographer these days, and it is no surprise, given that the top camera phones on the market are capable of fighting head-on with luxury compact cameras and...

Tammy Hembrow's Saski Collection re-launches Mesh Collection

The new range from fitness expert Tammy Hembrow’s clothing range Saski Collection has dropped its original Mesh Collection for the second time.   The new luxury athleisure label’s collection, which is worn by the likes of J Lo and available...

The Importance Of Choosing Quality Boat Supplies For Safety, Performance And Enjoyable Boating

Whether you are a recreational boater, an angler or someone who spends frequent weekends exploring the shoreline, investing in reliable boat supplies is essential. Quality supplies improve the functionality of your...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat