Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

What's in a name? How recruitment discriminates against 'foreign' applicants

  • Written by: Mladen Adamovic, Research Fellow in Management, Monash University

Since moving from Pakistan to Australia, Mariam Mohammed has gained a bachelor’s and a master’s degree[1], co-founded a social enterprise (teaching financial literacy to women) and made the Australian Financial Review’s 100 Women of Influence[2] list.

But there was a time she was so disheartened at not being able to get a job she considered changing her name[3] to something less “Muslim” and more “Anglo”.

Her experience is not unique.

In the past 50 years most Western countries have become more tolerant of cultural diversity. Laws now forbid overt forms of discrimination based on gender, ethnicity or age.

But unconscious biases remain – with one of the most well-documented being discrimination against job applicants with ethnic minority names.

Reviewing 123 resume studies

I have analysed 123 “resume studies”[4] to get a more fine-grained understanding of name-based discrimination in recruitment.

Resume studies typically involve[5] researchers responding to real job advertisements with very similar resumes of fictitious job candidates. In these studies, some resumes have names indicating an applicant comes from an ethnic minority group, while other resumes have more common names. This enables researchers to compare the responses for the different names.

My review covered studies conducted in Australia, Austria, Belgium, Britain, Canada, China, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Malaysia, Netherlands, Norway, Peru, Sweden, and the United States.

More than 95% of the studies identified high ethnic discrimination in recruitment. On average, ethnic minority applicants received about half as many positive responses to their job applications.

Read more: Vital Signs: the pros and cons of diversity in organisations[6]

Notable differences

There were, however, large differences in the degree of discrimination across the studies.

The following chart shows results from a selection of studies in different nations. The “net discrimination rate” is a common measure in resume studies. The higher the percentage, the higher the discrimination. So the resume studies show applicants with Moroccan names in Italy and African or German names in Ireland are more discriminated against than those with Turkish names in Germany.

Just three of the studies did not find any hiring discrimination against ethnic minorities. Only one reported hiring discrimination against the ethnic majority group – a study in Malaysia[7] finding a Chinese name was more helpful than a Malay name. (Chinese Malaysians represent less than a third[8] of Malaysia’s population, but are disproportionately represented in the business class[9].)

Yes, it really is the name that counts

The most noteworthy finding is the similar degree of discrimination against immigrants and the native-born children of immigrants (or second-generation immigrants).

Studies measured this effect through resumes for candidates with an ethnic minority name but with local educational qualification and work experience. Resumes for first-generation immigrants indicated attendance at foreign schools and universities and no local work experience. The response rate from recruiters was roughly the same.

These results show it is the ethnic minority name that’s the hindrance, rather than an assessment about a candidate’s language skills or a preference for local qualifications and work experience.

This point is underlined by US and Swedish[10] study findings that adopting an ethnic majority name improves job application success.

Read more: Bias creeps into reference checks, so is it time to ditch them?[11]

Anonymous resumes may not help

One common assumption among recruiters and human resource managers is that deleting the name of the job application should result in a more equal recruitment process.

But the research has returned mixed findings about anonymous resumes.

A 2012 Swedish study[12], for example, found anonymous resumes did indeed improve the chances for job candidates of non-Western origin (and also for female candidates).

In contrast, a 2015 study in France[13] reported that anonymous resumes increased ethnic discrimination in recruitment. The researchers suggest anonymous resumes might have led to harsher judgments of “negative signals” such as employment gaps.

So anonymous resumes might not be the solution. What recruiters need to focus on instead is training to recognise their unconscious biases and better evaluate resumes based only on applicants’ actual skills and experience.

References

  1. ^ master’s degree (www.thewestern.com.au)
  2. ^ 100 Women of Influence (www.afr.com)
  3. ^ considered changing her name (www.bodyandsoul.com.au)
  4. ^ analysed 123 “resume studies” (www.sciencedirect.com)
  5. ^ typically involve (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  6. ^ Vital Signs: the pros and cons of diversity in organisations (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ study in Malaysia (www.tandfonline.com)
  8. ^ less than a third (minorityrights.org)
  9. ^ business class (factsanddetails.com)
  10. ^ Swedish (www.journals.uchicago.edu)
  11. ^ Bias creeps into reference checks, so is it time to ditch them? (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ Swedish study (journals.sagepub.com)
  13. ^ a 2015 study in France (www.aeaweb.org)

Authors: Mladen Adamovic, Research Fellow in Management, Monash University

Read more https://theconversation.com/whats-in-a-name-how-recruitment-discriminates-against-foreign-applicants-160695

The Weekend Times Magazine

Tammy Hembrow's Saski Collection re-launches Mesh Collection

The new range from fitness expert Tammy Hembrow’s clothing range Saski Collection has dropped its original Mesh Collection for the second time.   The new luxury athleisure label’s collection, which is worn by the likes of J Lo and available...

Vacancies increase sharply in outer Sydney, as inner-city suburbs ease

The REINSW Vacancy Rate Survey results for July 2020 show that COVID-19 continues to impact the residential rental market. Vacancies in Sydney overall increased for the fifth successive month and now...

The Aussie Man Launches Debut Range of Men’s Grooming Products

Brand new Australian made men’s skincare company The Aussie Man has today announced the launch of their new range of organic skincare.  The Aussie Man uses hero natural ingredients such as...

Ben & Jerry’s launches ‘next-level ice cream’ phenomenon

Get ready, ice cream fans – a new ice cream revolution is coming to Australian shores! Ben & Jerry’s is today officially launching its new range of flavours to the...

Northern New South Wales may be facing a schoolies invasion

Northern New South Wales may be facing a “schoolies invasion” and unit, apartment and townhouse owners need to prepare – or be left with a potentially large clean-up bill. ...

Top Photographers in Sydney: A Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to documenting Sydney rich cultural heritage and varied landscapes photographer is essential. Sydney distinctive blend of urban environments and scenic beauty presents countless chances for imaginative photography. Numerous photographers focus...

Republicans have used a ‘law and order’ message to win elections before. This is why Trump could do it again

In 1991, Donald Trump’s mother, Mary, was mugged on a New York street. As Trump’s niece recounts in her new book, the young assailant slammed Mary’s head into her Rolls...

Choosing custom home builders in Perth: 7 questions to ask before you sign

Most people spend more time researching a new car than the builder who will spend the next year or more on their home. That is a costly imbalance. When you...

Dentists in Sydney: Your Guide to Dental Care

Sydney, Australia is home to the absolute best dental experts in the country. With a different range of services and specialties, dental specialists in Sydney take care of different needs...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat