Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Our states are crying poor. They wouldn't if they charged for rezoning like the ACT

  • Written by: Cameron Murray, Research Fellow - Henry Halloran Trust, University of Sydney

Throughout Australia, when land is rezoned from industrial to high-rise residential, a charge is levied to help fund the required infrastructure.

In NSW it is called an infrastructure contribution[1].

The NSW government is reviewing it[2] in order to cut “red tape[3]” and “fix the uncertainty[4]”.

They are words that ought to set off alarm bells. Queensland tells us how it is likely to play out.

A decade ago Queensland developers complained that a similar system lacked transparency[5] and was not proportional to underlying infrastructure needs[6]. So the Queensland government fixed it by by requiring each council to publish a standard schedule[7] of charges based on estimated infrastructure costs.

Problem solved. Right?

No, as it happens. In 2011 the Queensland Premier suddenly announced[8] a cap on charges. Overnight the system was disbanded and replaced with a fixed charge statewide.

Developers want lower infrastructure charges

The reality was that developers didn’t just want certainty and transparency, and they weren’t particularly keen on proportionality. They wanted lower charges.

In Victoria the property lobby is arguing for lower charges directly[9], without going through the charade about wanting less uncertainty and red tape.

To see the value of lower charges for developers, consider that current contributions in NSW are usually in the range of A$20,000 to A$70,000 per new apartment.

Read more: Four ways we can clean up corruption in land rezoning[10]

If a $50,000 charge was halved, for example, it would create a $2.5 million windfall for the owner of a site who developed 100 apartments. Add that up across all the sites owned by developers and it comes to billions.

Yet they are enriched by rezoning

It’s not as if developers can’t afford what’s charged. The moment their properties are rezoned they make much, much more.

Here’s an example.

A well-situated industrial site in Sydney’s inner west was bought for $8.5 million, rezoned high density residential, then sold again for $48.5 million[11]. The 470% windfall[12] was the result of a government decision: rezoning.

Our states are crying poor. They wouldn't if they charged for rezoning like the ACT The rezoned site of the Lewisham Estates in Sydney’s inner west. Inner West Council[13]

Not only are these windfalls enormous, they can add to the cost of infrastructure.

An industrial site in Altona North in Melbourne was bought by a developer for $8.7 million, rezoned for “comprehensive development” and then compulsorily acquired by the Victorian government for the West Gate Tunnel project for $22.5 million[14].

The Altona North rezoning added $14 million to the cost of the tunnel.

Our states are crying poor. They wouldn't if they charged for rezoning like the ACT Rezoned industrial land in Altona North. The Age[15]

Why not charge for rezoning?

The simplest way to fund council infrastructure would be to remove all fees and charges and sell the property rights granted through rezoning at market prices.

It could raise eight times what infrastructure charges do.

We know it can be done because the Australian Capital Territory has been doing it since 1971, charging 75%[16] of the market price for new property rights granted through rezoning.

Read more: Property developers pay developer charges, that’s why they argue against them[17]

In Sao Paulo, Brazil, the rights to develop to at higher densities have to be bought from the government at auction[18].

Developers won’t like it. Yet it would give them what they say they want, which is certainty. More than anyone else, they are acutely aware of what rezoning does to the value of their properties.

References

  1. ^ infrastructure contribution (www.planning.nsw.gov.au)
  2. ^ reviewing it (productivity.nsw.gov.au)
  3. ^ red tape (www.claytonutz.com)
  4. ^ fix the uncertainty (www.claytonutz.com)
  5. ^ lacked transparency (treasury.gov.au)
  6. ^ not proportional to underlying infrastructure needs (treasury.gov.au)
  7. ^ standard schedule (www.dlgrma.qld.gov.au)
  8. ^ suddenly announced (statements.qld.gov.au)
  9. ^ directly (udiavic.com.au)
  10. ^ Four ways we can clean up corruption in land rezoning (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ $48.5 million (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ 470% windfall (www.propertyobserver.com.au)
  13. ^ Inner West Council (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ $22.5 million (www.theage.com.au)
  15. ^ The Age (www.theage.com.au)
  16. ^ 75% (www.planning.act.gov.au)
  17. ^ Property developers pay developer charges, that’s why they argue against them (theconversation.com)
  18. ^ at auction (www.iadb.org)

Authors: Cameron Murray, Research Fellow - Henry Halloran Trust, University of Sydney

Read more https://theconversation.com/our-states-are-crying-poor-they-wouldnt-if-they-charged-for-rezoning-like-the-act-142838

The Weekend Times Magazine

How to work from home and not get divorced

Covid has triggered life-changing decisions for some people and has put a lot of relationship strain on couples. The stress of working from home and having to home school the...

Kmart at home: Why Australians keep coming back for stylish living at everyday prices

There was a time when discount department stores were often associated with buying the basics. A kettle, a mop or a few household necessities would do the job, but style...

The Vital Role of Indemnity Insurance in Nursing

In modern healthcare, nurses operate within an increasingly complex professional environment that exposes them to a wide range of risks. Their responsibilities extend from direct patient care to managing complex...

Paid parental leave needs an overhaul if governments want us to have ‘one for the country’

As Australia and New Zealand face the realities of slow growth, or even a decline in population, it’s time to ask if their governments are doing enough. Especially if they...

Car Removal Melbourne and Clearing Vehicles the Easy Way

Unwanted vehicles can quietly become a problem, occupying space, losing value, and creating unnecessary stress. Car removal Melbourne offers a practical way to deal with cars that are no longer useful...

Understanding Root Canal Treatment – What You Need to Know

For many people, hearing the term root canal treatment brings immediate anxiety. It’s one of the most feared dental procedures, often associated with pain and discomfort. However, this perception is outdated...

Why Sydney Never Stops Welcoming the World

Every weekend, Australia's harbour city reminds us why international tourism matters. Walk through Circular Quay on a Saturday morning and you'll hear dozens of languages before you've finished your coffee. Families photograph...

Men’s style: where to buy it and how to build it

Most men are not taught style. They are taught how to work, drive, earn money and solve problems. Fashion and presentation are often treated as secondary concerns, something instinctive that men...

How Offroad Caravans For Sale Offer Freedom, Durability And Adventure-Ready Performance

Australians who love exploring rugged landscapes and remote travel destinations often look for reliable offroad caravans for sale that can withstand tough terrain while providing a comfortable home on wheels...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat