Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Pauline Hanson’s High Court appeal will put freedom of speech to the test

  • Written by: Weekend Times

Senator Pauline Hanson has persuaded the High Court to hear an appeal against a finding that she breached section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 by publishing a tweet about Greens

Senator Mehreen Faruqi.

At stake is the constitutional validity of section 18C. The section makes it unlawful for a person to engage in a public act that is reasonably likely to offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate another person or group, if it is done because of their race, colour or national or ethnic origin.

What started the conflict?

When Queen Elizabeth II died in September 2022, Faruqi published a tweet that included the line: “I cannot mourn the leader of a racist empire built on stolen lives, land and wealth of colonised people”.

Hanson tweeted in reply that Faruqi’s tweet appalled and disgusted her. She claimed that when Faruqi immigrated to Australia, she took every advantage of the country, and concluded that: “It’s clear you’re not happy, so pack your bags and piss off back to Pakistan”.

Faruqi made a complaint to the Human Rights Commission that Hanson’s tweet breached section 18C. Hanson declined to participate in a conciliation process.

Faruqi then took the matter to the Federal Court. At first instance, Justice Angus Stewart found Hanson’s conduct in publishing the tweet was unlawful under section 18C and didn’t fall within a defence. He ordered Hanson’s tweet be deleted and that she pay Faruqi’s legal costs.

Hanson then appealed to the full court of the Federal Court. It upheld the lower court’s decision. The High Court has now agreed to hear a final appeal by Hanson. It is likely to be heard early next year.

The issues

The case will raise two issues concerning the constitutional validity of section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act. The first is whether the Commonwealth had the power to validly enact section 18C. The second is whether 18C breaches the implied freedom of political communication.

While these issues have previously been addressed by lower courts, they have not yet been decided by the High Court. This means the outcome may have broader ramifications for other laws, such as those banning hate groups, restricting protests and banning the use of political slogans.

Legislative power and the external affairs power

The Commonwealth Parliament cannot enact laws on any subject it wants. It can only enact laws that fall within certain powers conferred on it by the Constitution. One of those powers is the external affairs power in section 51(xxix) of the Constitution. It allows the Commonwealth Parliament to enact laws to implement obligations in treaties that Australia has ratified.

The question is whether section 18C, in fact, implements Australia’s treaty obligations in article 20(2) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights or article 4 of the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination.

The essential problem is that 18C covers conduct at the serious level (that is, conduct that humiliates and intimidates), as well as less serious conduct (such as that which offends or insults).

In contrast, the treaty obligations require the prohibition of very serious acts. Article 20(2) provides that any advocacy of racial hatred that incites discrimination, hostility or violence shall be prohibited by law. Article 4 deals with inciting racial discrimination or violence on the basis of race.

In contrast, section 18C doesn’t deal with inciting hatred, hostility, discrimination or violence. It deals instead with how a person targeted on the basis of their race might reasonably feel – not whether others are incited to act.

These treaty provisions were set at a high level of seriousness because they also recognise the importance of freedom of speech. For example, article 4 is subject to the qualification that the parties to the treaty must act with due regard to the principles in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the rights set out in article 5, which include freedom of opinion and expression.

The question for the High Court, therefore, is how far a law can drift away from the express terms of a treaty and still be treated as valid because it is implementing the treaty’s obligations. This is especially important when the words of the treaty were chosen carefully to balance otherwise conflicting rights.

The full court of the Federal Court justified the lower-level conduct made unlawful by section 18C on the ground it “nips in the bud” conduct that may later escalate into the more serious conduct addressed by the treaties.

This would seem to expand an already very broad external affairs power into one where only a loose connection with a treaty is needed. This appeal will test whether the High Court accepts such an expansion.

The implied freedom of political communication

Political communication can sometimes involve statements that are offensive or insulting to others. Both participants in this tweet exchange seemed willing to offend and insult for political purposes.

The High Court has held that laws that restrict freedom of political communication are invalid unless they are reasonably appropriate and adapted to serve a legitimate purpose that is compatible with the system of government imposed by the Constitution.

Shutting down political debate has not been regarded as a “legitimate purpose” because it is contrary to the democratic system. There must be another purpose, such as protecting people from violence or harm, for the law to be justified.

In a recent case concerning the American commentator Candace Owens Farmer, the High Court recognised that protecting segments of the community from intimidation or vilification is a legitimate purpose.

However, it considered that protecting the feelings or sensitivities of a segment of the community from being hurt is not a legitimate purpose. Terms such as “offend” or “insult” fall into a grey area in which the High Court has found it difficult to articulate the constitutional boundaries.

This issue will be relevant also to the challenge Ismail v Queensland to the recitation of certain political slogans in Queensland.

The bigger picture

In fraught political times, freedom of speech is put to the test. While parliaments make the laws they consider necessary to support social cohesion by restricting speech, it is the High Court that ultimately decides whether they breach the Constitution by unduly restricting freedom of political communication.

In the next 12 months, the High Court will face a slew of such cases. Hopefully this will result in greater clarity on the issue, so that parliaments and the people can be clear about the boundaries of free speech and legislative powers.

Anne Twomey has received funding from the Australian Research Council and occasionally does consulting work for Parliaments, government bodies and inter-governmental bodies. She also has a YouTube Channel, Constitutional Clarion, that discusses constitutional issues.

The Weekend Times Magazine

Launching Weekly Campaigns with Zero Dev Involvement: The Headless Advantage

Marketing teams are forever tasked with more and more quickly. It wasn't long ago that launching a campaign weekly was a stretch goal and not a minimum viable timeframe. Today...

Could You Furnish and Equip a Whole House with IKEA Products?

IKEA has long been known as the global giant of affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. From minimalist Scandinavian sofas to clever kitchen gadgets, the Swedish retailer has built its reputation on making...

Elevating Events with Convenience and Style: Why Hiring a Coffee Cart is the Perfect Choice

The humble coffee break has transformed into a focal point of social connection, productivity, and hospitality. Whether it's a corporate function, wedding celebration, community festival, or pop-up market, the presence...

Year 12 Tutoring For Better Exam Preparation And Academic Confidence

The final year of high school is one of the most important periods in a student's academic journey. It is a time when assessment results, examination performance, and study habits...

How to work from home and not get divorced

Covid has triggered life-changing decisions for some people and has put a lot of relationship strain on couples. The stress of working from home and having to home school the...

A Complete Guide to Hiring Shipping Containers

Shipping containers are used for transferring various types of products over long distances, usually from one country to another. They are also used as storage containers. But people who hire...

Meet Untamed Natural Beauty! Breathtaking Journeys Await You in Komodo Island

Designed by Freepik Komodo Island, part of Indonesia’s Komodo National Park, offers a truly remarkable escape into nature. Known for its rugged beauty, pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and unique wildlife, it...

Catch a Flight to Broome for a Tropical Adventure

If you’re dreaming of a getaway that combines tropical beauty, rich culture, and a sense of adventure, look no further than Broome. Tucked away in Western Australia’s Kimberley region, Broome...

Catering Boxes: Practical Packaging That Supports Food Quality and Presentation

Reliable Catering boxes are essential for food businesses that need to transport, store, and present meals safely and professionally. From cafés and bakeries to large-scale caterers and event organisers, catering boxes...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat