Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Winston Peters says ‘diversity is disunity’ – what does the evidence tell us?

  • Written by: Weekend Times
Dean Purcell/NZ Herald via Getty Images

When New Zealand First leader Winston Peters recently announced his party’s immigration policy by saying “diversity is weakness and disunity”, he deliberately set himself apart from

the political pack.

It’s become common to hear politicians, community leaders and businesses extol the benefits of diversity. And when the five smaller-party leaders were asked during a recent TV debate whether they supported the idea, all but Peters raised their hands.

Nonetheless, New Zealand has not been immune to questioning whether diversity – and especially diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies – benefit organisations and countries. US President Donald Trump made purging the federal government of DEI programmes a priority.

So, what does the evidence tell us? The most influential work at a company level is in three reports from global management consultancy McKinsey & Company. The third, published in 2023, was titled “Diversity Matters Even More” and looked at 1,200 companies in 23 countries, including New Zealand.

Referring to gender and ethnic diversity in leadership, it concluded companies that “make diversity happen have better financial returns”. McKinsey’s analysis has its critics. But other work has tended to support the basic findings.

The Wall Street Journal, for example, has found diversity is associated with innovation. And a Bloomberg analysis of data since 2018 found female representation on boards and in leadership is associated with higher returns.

Diversity NZ style

In New Zealand, then Treasury Secretary Gabriel Makhlouf said in 2014, “Diversity doesn’t compromise performance. It’s a performance advantage”.

In 2020, the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the terrorist attack on Christchurch Mosques also made the case that diversity in leadership and policy aided social cohesion rather than undermined it.

As a judge for the Diversity Awards over the past decade I’ve observed a wide range of organisations – governmental, sporting, corporate – avoiding the political noise and pressing on with diversity and inclusion policies.

In 2026, the overall winner was New Zealand Football, highlighting how sports organisations and teams have embraced ethnic and gender diversity over recent decades.

High Performance Sport New Zealand’s 2020 report, “True Innovation Requires Diversity”, stressed that “successful people seek out diversity and utilise difference to innovate”.

In 2018, Sport New Zealand-Ihi Aotearoa adopted a campaign to increase gender diversity, with considerable success by 2022.

There is extensive research supporting the association between recognising diversity and sporting success, whether it be at the local park or on the world stage.

Beyond the sports field and corporate office, there is also evidence that countries benefit from the multilingualism a diverse population can provide. A World Economic Forum review in 2018 noted that Switzerland attributes 10% of its GDP to the four national languages spoken there.

The United Kingdom, in contrast, loses 3.5% of its GDP due to poor policies and support for linguistic competence.

This might be one area where New Zealand can do better. While there are three official languages (te reo Māori, Sign Language and English), a broader language policy would normalise and celebrate multilingualism and help bridge different language communities within New Zealand – and with major trading partners.

A super-diverse future

Finally, there is a demographic imperative. New Zealand is already am extremely diverse country. There is a significant Indigenous population and 30% of New Zealanders were born overseas (43% in Auckland).

The drop in the fertility rate over the past decade means immigration will become more important as a major contributor to both population growth and labour supply. It will also inevitably add to the country’s cultural diversity.

By the 2040s, one in three New Zealanders will be a member of one of the country’s Asian communities, while Māori will make up one in five New Zealanders and one in three school-age children.

The demographic reality is that Aotearoa New Zealand is already culturally and linguistically diverse and will become more so over coming decades. The question is how to respond to this inevitability.

From sports and business to government and education, the evidence suggests diversity and inclusion policies and programmes lead to greater social cohesion and can improve economic outcomes.

But this comes with a proviso. If there is an association between ethnic group membership and low socioeconomic status and marginalisation, there is the potential for anti-social behaviour and even radicalisation.

This could indeed fit Winston Peters’ warning of “disunity”. But that would not be the result of diversity itself, more an inability or unwillingness to manage it well.

Paul Spoonley received funding from the Ministry of Business and Innovation as part of the Capturing Diversity Dividend research programme. He has been a judge for the Diversity Awards run by Te Uru Tangata, previously known as Diversity Works.

The Weekend Times Magazine

How Pest Control Albury Protects Homes And Businesses From Harmful Pests

Residents and business owners in regional New South Wales understand the challenges that seasonal pests can bring. Many turn to Pest Control Albury to keep their properties safe, hygienic and free...

Mining Hose for Dewatering and Water Transfer Applications

Dewatering systems need to move water efficiently while equipment and hoses may be relocated as site conditions change. The mining hose should be selected around the actual duty and conveyed material...

Science Tutoring and Building Strong Foundations for Academic Success

For students tackling complex scientific concepts, science tutoring provides essential support that turns confusion into clarity. Science subjects demand more than memorisation. They require logical thinking, problem-solving skills, and the ability...

The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Removalists for Your Next Move

Whether you are relocating for work, upgrading your living space, or downsizing, the process of moving often requires careful planning, organization, and assistance. One of the most important steps in...

Elevating Events with Convenience and Style: Why Hiring a Coffee Cart is the Perfect Choice

The humble coffee break has transformed into a focal point of social connection, productivity, and hospitality. Whether it's a corporate function, wedding celebration, community festival, or pop-up market, the presence...

How to work from home and not get divorced

Covid has triggered life-changing decisions for some people and has put a lot of relationship strain on couples. The stress of working from home and having to home school the...

Eradicate Sugar To Aid Good Mental Health

It’s R U OK Day tomorrow, Thursday 10 September, the national day of action for people to check in with their peers, family and friends to see if they’re ok.  Twenty...

Property app Instarent

Property self-management soars during COVID lockdown The innovative PropTech app, Instarent, has seen exponential growth during the COVID -19 lockdown, reporting a 400 per cent increase in users during...

Best Ways to Promote a Healthy Lifestyle in Your Kitchen

Healthy lifestyle – it is what many of us are trying to achieve, yet it seems as if we’re constantly facing obstacles that keep us away from attaining our goals...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat