Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Federal government hasn’t applied for any preventative detention orders for ex-detainees, saying it takes a long time

  • Written by: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

The federal government has so far not applied to have any of those released from immigration detention after the November High Court judgement re-detained, according to figures released on Monday.

The government raced legislation through parliament in December to enable it to apply to a court for preventative detention orders.

Under sustained opposition questioning in the House of Representatives, Immigration Minister Andrew Giles said the government’s regime was modelled on the Coalition’s high risk offenders legislation, which had seen a lengthy time for any application to be made.

Figures released during Senate estimates hearings showed 24 of the 149 detainees released have been arrested and charged with offences - six for breaches of visa conditions and 18 for offences under state and territory law.

At the end of January, 113 of the ex-detainees had been required to wear ankle bracelets.

Details of the ex-detainees’ offences committed before their detention were released on Monday. They showed seven had been convicted of murder or attempted murder and 37 of sexually-based offences, including child sex offences.

Some 72 had convictions for assault and violent offending, kidnapping, and armed robbery; another 16 had convictions for domestic violence and stalking.

Thirteen had convictions for serious drug offences, less than five for serious people smuggling crimes and less than five for offences described as a “Low level or no criminality”.

Numbers include overseas offending in some cases.

The ex-detainees cannot be deported because no other country will take them or they are stateless.

The opposition unsuccessfully pressed Giles on whether any of the 36 people who were not wearing ankle bracelets had committed offences since leaving detention. In Senate estimates the government took the question on notice.

Giles declined to go into “operational matters”.

He said “the management of everyone in that cohort has been subject to the expert advice of the men and women of the community protection board”.

Giles repeatedly stressed the people had had to be released under the High Court decision, which would have been the case under any government. The court found they could not be indefinitely detained.

“Since then, we have been working around the clock to ensure the community is kept safe.

"We have done so by putting in place layers of protection. One of which is, of course, the regime that was the subject of legislation […] at the end of last year” providing for preventative detention.

Giles said the government’s preventative detention regime was modelled on the high-risk offenders scheme of the Coalition government.

“It took more than three years for the first continuing detention order application after that regime was enacted.

"And 10 months was the shortest period of time for an application to be made to the court under the members opposite.”

Opposition home affairs spokesman James Paterson said Senate processes had forced the government to “cough up” a whole lot of information. “Hopefully the government actually gets off their proverbial and makes an application to the court.”

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more https://theconversation.com/federal-government-hasnt-applied-for-any-preventative-detention-orders-for-ex-detainees-saying-it-takes-a-long-time-223339

The Weekend Times Magazine

The 29-year-old Australian Revolutionising The Edible Collagen Market

Known as ‘Nature’s Botox’, scientific research shows collagen is not only anti-ageing and good for skin, but also optimises health, ligaments, muscle recovery, the gut, and helps heal the digestive...

Swimming with whales: you must know the risks and when it’s best to keep your distance

Three people were injured last month in separate humpback whale encounters off the Western Australia coast. The incidents happened during snorkelling tours on Ningaloo Reef when swimmers came too close to...

How to Care for Your Dental Veneers: Tips from Experts

Dental veneers are a popular cosmetic dentistry solution that enhances smiles by covering imperfections such as discoloration, chips, or gaps. Among the different types available, porcelain veneers stand out for...

How to Simplify Your Retirement Planning with SMSF Setup Online

Managing your retirement savings can feel overwhelming, but for many Australians, creating a self-managed super fund (SMSF) offers greater flexibility and control. What’s even more appealing today is the ability...

Why External Blinds and Awnings Are Essential for Comfortable and Protected Outdoor Spaces

Creating outdoor areas that remain functional, comfortable, and visually appealing throughout the year requires effective protection from sun, wind, and changing weather. Installing external blinds and awnings provides a practical solution...

The Hidden Financial World Most Australians Never See

Most Australians know their local bank. Few realise that an enormous financial market now operates largely behind the scenes. Private credit funds quietly finance office towers, apartment buildings, renewable energy projects, factories...

Making these five clever moving mistakes will cost you both money and time

Moving to a new location can be a thrilling adventure, but it can also be costly and stressful. Because so much packing, planning, and logistics are involved, it is easy...

Could You Furnish and Equip a Whole House with IKEA Products?

IKEA has long been known as the global giant of affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. From minimalist Scandinavian sofas to clever kitchen gadgets, the Swedish retailer has built its reputation on making...

Prime Minister interview with Karl Stefanovic and Alison Langdon, Today

KARL STEFANOVIC: Joining us now from Kirribilli House in Sydney. PM, good morning to you. Thank you for your time.    PRIME MINISTER: G’day Karl.   STEFANOVIC: The Premiers don't seem to be listening...