Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

the coup in Myanmar is partly about protecting the economic interests of the military elite

  • Written by: Htwe Htwe Thein, Associate professor, Curtin University

The actions of the Myanmar military in arresting members of the government in dawn raids on February 1, the day parliament was set to convene, have been met with shock and dismay both within the country and around the world.

Why would the military stage a coup to depose a democratically-elected government of which it had been part? Why do it just before the government began a second term?

There are several plausible explanations, but one that has not received enough attention is the desire of the military to protect its wealth and business interests in Myanmar.

It should not be underestimated.

For decades the military has amassed wealth by controlling the state bureaucracy and establishing near-monopolies in key sectors.

The reform agenda of the civilian-led National League for Democracy government threatened to weaken - albeit gradually over time - this lucrative system of crony capitalism.

Read more: Myanmar's military reverts to its old strong-arm behaviour — and the country takes a major step backwards[1]

There is a saying in Myanmar that you “can touch the hair bun on top of my head, but don’t you dare touch the wallet tucked away at my waist”.

The consolidation of civilian rule likely after November 2020’s election threatened previously-untouchable wallets.

Military crony capitalism

Political reforms initiated in 2011 allowed the previously-banned National League for Democracy to contest the 2015 general election and win it in a landslide.

But in the decades leading up to 2011 two military-owned conglomerates, Myanmar Economic Corporation (MEC[2]) and Myanmar Economic Holding Ltd (MEHL[3]) used privatisations[4] to grab publicly-owned enterprises at fire-sale prices[5].

As well, military leaders and associates of military leaders grabbed licenses, land and economic concessions.

Read more: Ethical minefields: the dirty business of doing deals with Myanmar's military[6]

While there have been important reforms[7] in Myanmar over the past decade, including a stronger role for a private sector and international investors, the military has maintained its economic clout.

Its conglomerates control businesses and investments in sectors ranging from beer, tobacco and consumables to mines, mills, tourism, property development and telecommunications.

Indeed, this has posed a dilemma[8] for many international businesses that have been accused by the United Nations[9] and Amnesty International[10] of failing to respect human rights by engaging businesses controlled by the military.

The threat from civilian government

The first National League for Democracy government (2015-2020) was reluctant to directly or decisively target the interests of the military, although its opening of key sectors to competition and investment acted as counterweight.

It was intent on tackling the country’s deep-grained corruption[11] in government–business relations, but with weak impact on the businesses owned by the military.

However, in November 2018 a National League for Democracy spokesperson pointed to the military domination of key parts of the economy and stated that the government bureaucracy – historically dominated by retired military personnel - was a major stumbling block[12] to progress and would be an important target for reform after the 2020 election.

Read more: Why Myanmar is rising up in collective fury after a military coup – The Conversation Weekly podcast[13]

The civilian-led government began to gradually de-militarise the country. A major achievement was the 2019 transfer of the general administration department to civilian control[14].

This department, previously in the military-controlled ministry of home affairs, has been depicted as the spine of the government of Myanmar, with the power to appoint government officials across the country.

the coup in Myanmar is partly about protecting the economic interests of the military elite Families gather near the bodies of victims after a landslide at a jade mining site in Kachin State, Myanmar, July 2 2020. ZAW MOE HTET/EPA

Many were shocked that the military had been forced to relinquish control. It was a sign of the weakening grip of the military over the government administration and patronage – which had been at the heart of its ability to accumulate and protect its wealth.

Another achievement was a series of changes to the Myanmar Gemstones Law[15] that threatened military-dominated enterprises for whom the danger-ridden jade mining[16] industry had been extraordinarily lucrative.

We do not know exactly what the National League for Democracy was planning next for jade mining or its commitment to meaningful reform[17], but we can be sure that strengthened civilian oversight would have loomed large as a concern for the military.

International pressure

The military coup intensifies pressures on international businesses to take a stand on the ethical impacts of their interactions with Myanmar, especially for businesses in direct partnerships with the military.

The decision of the multinational Kirin Brewery Company that brews Australia’s Tooheys, XXXX and James Squire beers to exit[18] its partnership with a Myanmar military-owned business is a high-profile sign of the pressures on investors.

International trade sanctions are likely to return if things don’t improve, but many businesses in countries neighbouring Myanmar are unlikely to be swayed.

As civil disobedience gains traction it remains unclear whether the military coup will succeed. What is clear is that the fight for democracy in Myanmar is also a fight against military-dominated crony capitalism.

References

  1. ^ Myanmar's military reverts to its old strong-arm behaviour — and the country takes a major step backwards (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ MEC (www.mecwebsite.com)
  3. ^ MEHL (en.wikipedia.org)
  4. ^ privatisations (www.researchgate.net)
  5. ^ fire-sale prices (www.tandfonline.com)
  6. ^ Ethical minefields: the dirty business of doing deals with Myanmar's military (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ important reforms (www.taylorfrancis.com)
  8. ^ dilemma (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ United Nations (www.ohchr.org)
  10. ^ Amnesty International (www.amnesty.org)
  11. ^ deep-grained corruption (asiatimes.com)
  12. ^ stumbling block (www.mmtimes.com)
  13. ^ Why Myanmar is rising up in collective fury after a military coup – The Conversation Weekly podcast (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ civilian control (www.frontiermyanmar.net)
  15. ^ Myanmar Gemstones Law (oxfordbusinessgroup.com)
  16. ^ jade mining (www.globalwitness.org)
  17. ^ meaningful reform (www.myanmar-now.org)
  18. ^ exit (www.kirinholdings.co.jp)

Authors: Htwe Htwe Thein, Associate professor, Curtin University

Read more https://theconversation.com/taking-care-of-business-the-coup-in-myanmar-is-partly-about-protecting-the-economic-interests-of-the-military-elite-154727

The Weekend Times Magazine

Why Pigmentation Removal Melbourne Treatments Help Restore Even Skin Tone

Skin pigmentation concerns are common among individuals of all ages. Dark spots, uneven skin tone, and sun damage can affect the appearance of the skin and often develop due to...

The Importance of Commercial Fencing: Enhancing Security and Aesthetics

In the world of business, the first impression often sets the tone for what’s to come. When it comes to properties, one of the first things people notice is the...

Weekend getaways from Perth

You Are in Perth, Australia and You Want to Get Away for the Weekend: What Are the Options? Perth is one of the most isolated cities in the world, but that...

Could You Furnish and Equip a Whole House with IKEA Products?

IKEA has long been known as the global giant of affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. From minimalist Scandinavian sofas to clever kitchen gadgets, the Swedish retailer has built its reputation on making...

Weekend Escapes Closer to Home: Making the Most of Every Litre

Rising fuel prices are changing more than household budgets—they are changing the way Australians holiday. For many families, a weekend away has traditionally meant filling the car and heading several hundred...

Turning fashion into power - Beauty with Brains

During this unfortunate time of our lives there’s a hidden gem business which keeps the hopes up for many lives of women of all walks of life. Fashion...

Ben & Jerry’s launches ‘next-level ice cream’ phenomenon

Get ready, ice cream fans – a new ice cream revolution is coming to Australian shores! Ben & Jerry’s is today officially launching its new range of flavours to the...

Elevating Events with Convenience and Style: Why Hiring a Coffee Cart is the Perfect Choice

The humble coffee break has transformed into a focal point of social connection, productivity, and hospitality. Whether it's a corporate function, wedding celebration, community festival, or pop-up market, the presence...

Car subscription offers part-time workers access to a car during COVID-19

New research commissioned by Carly, Australia’s first flexible car subscription provider, surveyed more than 1200 Australians and found that 48% of part time workers would consider car subscription instead of...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat