Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Identifying the losers (and surprising winners) from phasing out stamp duty

  • Written by: Lawrence Uren, Senior Lecturer in Economics, University of Melbourne

More than ever as we emerge from the crisis we are going to have to get the most out of our economy.

Swapping stamp duty for land tax as the ACT government[1] is doing (over 20 years) and the NSW government[2] is planning (using an opt-in arrangement), is one of the best ways the tax system can help.

This graph from the federal treasury’s 2015 tax discussion paper[3] makes the point.

It says the “marginal excess burden” (damage) done by real estate stamp duty amounts to 70 cents for each dollar raised.

It discourages people and businesses from changing addresses as often as they should, meaning workers live further away from their work than they would and are reluctant to move to where there is better work.

Identifying the losers (and surprising winners) from phasing out stamp duty Tax discussion paper, Australian Treasury March 2015[4] In contrast, treasury found the marginal excess burden of land tax was negative. Land tax makes sure land was used for its most useful purpose and not left idle. Efficiency-wise it makes sense to swap one for the other, but as with all changes there will be winners and losers, some of them surprising. In our just-published study[5], we use real-world data on living arrangements from the Melbourne Institute’s Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia[6] survey and data on house prices and stamp duty rates from the Real Estate Institute Australia in an attempt to work out who the winners and losers will be. We find that overall the swap should reduce the purchase price for home buyers, increase the sale price for sellers, increase the total number of transactions and reduce the degree of mismatch in housing. It should also increase the rate of home ownership. Young adults, particularly those who are currently having difficulty saving for a deposit would be better off. Current homeowners would generally be worse off. Renters would benefit because they are currently excluded from home ownership. Older landlords, perhaps surprisingly, would also benefit. In many cases the increase in the value of their houses would outweigh the cost of the land tax. Our findings raise a challenge for governments. Read more: Axing stamp duty is a great idea, but NSW is going about it the wrong way[7] In the long run the swap would improve the working of the economy, but in the short run it will hurt many current voters. A gradual transition – either through a very long phase in (of the kind adopted by the ACT) or by allowing households to select into different tax systems (as NSW is planning) would help make the switch more palatable. But the sooner we start, the better.

References

  1. ^ ACT government (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ NSW government (www.treasury.nsw.gov.au)
  3. ^ tax discussion paper (treasury.gov.au)
  4. ^ Tax discussion paper, Australian Treasury March 2015 (treasury.gov.au)
  5. ^ just-published study (papers.ssrn.com)
  6. ^ Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (melbourneinstitute.unimelb.edu.au)
  7. ^ Axing stamp duty is a great idea, but NSW is going about it the wrong way (theconversation.com)

Authors: Lawrence Uren, Senior Lecturer in Economics, University of Melbourne

Read more https://theconversation.com/identifying-the-losers-and-surprising-winners-from-phasing-out-stamp-duty-154935

The Weekend Times Magazine

The Hidden Financial World Most Australians Never See

Most Australians know their local bank. Few realise that an enormous financial market now operates largely behind the scenes. Private credit funds quietly finance office towers, apartment buildings, renewable energy projects, factories...

Top 6 Ways Robotic Pool Cleaners Save You Time and Money

A pool is a great investment that improves the aesthetics of your home and also offers a fun and enjoyable way to relax, exercise or entertain loved ones. However, many...

Why Probiotics for Dogs Are Important for Digestive and Overall Health

Maintaining a healthy digestive system is essential for a dog's wellbeing, and probiotics for dogs have become increasingly popular among pet owners looking to support their pet’s health naturally. The digestive...

Microbes living on air a global phenomenon

UNSW researchers have found their previous discovery of bacteria living on air in Antarctica is likely a process that occurs globally, further supporting the potential existence of microbial life on...

Coasting through Australia: 5 things you need to know

No matter where you choose to explore, you can never go wrong with Australia. The best time to spend time on the water in Australia is during the autumn and...

How Legal Representation Helps Solve Family Disputes

Family disputes can be some of the most challenging legal matters individuals face. Issues involving separation, parenting arrangements, property division, and family responsibilities often involve both legal complexities and emotional...

Make Your Holiday Merry with Christmas Inflatables

The holiday season is all about bringing joy and festivity to your home or event. One of the most fun and visually captivating ways to do this is by incorporating...

Buying Your First Pontoon Boat? Here's What to Look For!

If you're a water lover and eager to cruise peaceful inland waterways more often, a pontoon boat is a great way to do it. Plus, it's largely considered the easiest...

Reliable Air Conditioning Installation for Comfortable Living

When it comes to creating a comfortable indoor environment, having a dependable cooling system is essential—especially during Melbourne’s unpredictable summers. A professional air conditioning installation not only ensures optimal temperature control...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat