Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

View from The Hill: Mathias Cormann offers blunt advice on countering populism and reforming the economy

  • Written by: Weekend Times

Mathias Cormann, these days secretary-general of OECD but formerly Liberal finance minister, is professionally non-partisan in his current role. But that’s not quite the same as being non-political.

In a weekend

speech Cormann delivered a sharp message into an environment of surging populism – a message both sides of politics, but especially the Coalition, would do well to take to heart.

Cormann warned that “we all need to engage” with what was being offered by populism “because it is winning an audience it did not have even five years ago”.

Addressing the Centre for Independent Studies, Cormann said the grievances populism spoke to were real. They included real incomes having gone backwards, a generation locked out of the housing market, high energy bills, infrastructure failing to keep up with need and communities feeling they weren’t consulted about decisions.

“Anyone who dismisses those grievances as ignorance has not understood what the data is clearly telling us,” Cormann said.

“But a correct diagnosis of the symptoms does not validate the prescription seemingly getting traction.”

For instance, a return to protectionist policies would be counterproductive, he said. “Regional Australians whose support the populists court are the ones who paid most for the old tariff wall.”

Similarly, arbitrary caps on migration, regardless of their effect on business, hospitals, aged care and the universities, would be harmful.

Rather, the answer was to fix the issues concerning people about migration – housing supply, infrastructure, services and the composition of the intake – “not to shrink the country”.

“Because the evidence is clear. OECD research across Australia’s regions finds that where more migrants arrived, employment among Australian-born workers grew faster, not slower, with no measurable effect on their wages.

"Migrants to Australia in aggregate are better educated than migrants to any other OECD country. That is a policy choice that Australia has made. By international comparison Australia actually runs a highly successful and economically beneficial migration programme.”

Cormann warned:

Mainstream parties that respond to a populist surge by adopting its economics do not recover their voters. They lose twice: once to the original, which the electorate will always prefer to the copy, and once to the centre, which has nowhere else left to go.

He said the evidence was extensive, across Britain, France, Germany and elsewhere.

Mainstream parties that borrowed the insurgents’ agenda shrank while the insurgents grew.

The parties that have held their ground did so by out-performing the populists, not by imitating them.

Deliver homes, lower energy costs, real wage growth and a credible budget, and the populist tide recedes. Mimic the populists, and you simply confirm that they were right all along.

The way to defeat populism is to solve the problems it feeds on.

Cormann said he wanted to put his message plainly.

“There is no shortcut to a lower cost of living. There is no populist shortcut, through tariffs, caps and state banks. There is no interventionist shortcut, through subsidies and regulation and handouts.

"A government that tries to re-regulate its way to higher wages, or to subsidise its way to a manufacturing renaissance, is making the same error as the populist, even if cloaked in a more respectable vocabulary.”

He said the only way round was the long way. That was an economy producing more, competing harder and growing faster than its costs.

“It is the only agenda that has ever worked in this country. It is the only agenda that will work again. And anyone offering you a quicker route is offering you a poorer country.

"And notice where populism of the left and populism of the right both end up: different grievances, different language, but the same economics. A problem that presents on both flanks of politics can only be solved by rebuilding, in the centre, the consensus for reform that both sides once shared.”

Cormann set out a detailed reform program he called “the only cost-of-living agenda there is”. It is one that most observers would see as unlikely to be implemented any time soon. But it does chime with ideas put by former Liberal deputy leader Josh Frydenberg in his just released autobiography A Grateful Son.

Cormann argued for comprehensive tax reform, including an overhaul of the GST, as part of a switch from our excessive reliance on taxing income.

“Taxes on income supply more than 60% of Australia’s revenue, against an OECD average of about 36%. The GST rate is half the OECD average, on barely half the base. And stamp duty is the most damaging tax in the federation.

"End the reliance on bracket creep by indexing thresholds and fund it honestly through a broader consumption base and more efficient taxation of land and property.”

Liberals criticised Frydenberg for daring to be radical about the GST; they will be hoping no one focuses too much on the fact that Cormann is on the same page as his former ministerial colleague.

There’s much more besides on Cormann’s agenda. He advocates maximising the use of AI – which he sees as “the biggest productivity lift of our lifetime” – by taking a light touch approach, a position that will be contested by many.

Make Australia the easiest place in the region to deploy artificial intelligence, through pro-innovation regulation, data access and energy for the data centres already lifting growth.

The productivity dividend from AI will go to the countries that adopt fastest, not to those that regulate first.

So apply the laws Australia already has, through the regulators it already has, rather than building a standalone AI regulator. Treat data centres as national infrastructure with a twelve-month approvals clock. Open government data by default. And get the technology into small businesses, hospitals and classrooms, where the productivity gap is largest.

Michelle Grattan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

The Weekend Times Magazine

All the Things You Need to Know Before Flying to Cairns

Cairns is the gateway to Queensland, offering a tropical climate and a relaxing atmosphere, making it an ideal destination for outdoor activities. The city has iconic destinations, charming cafes, lively...

How pool putty can be a lifesaver when it comes to pool repairs

Pool putty is a great way to repair your pool. It works well for all types of repairs, especially when you need to patch up a hole in the liner...

Buying Your First Pontoon Boat? Here's What to Look For!

If you're a water lover and eager to cruise peaceful inland waterways more often, a pontoon boat is a great way to do it. Plus, it's largely considered the easiest...

Building a Custom Home on a Narrow Lot in Mandurah: What the Block Size Is Not Telling You

Property listings in Mandurah's established suburbs increasingly include lots that look modest on paper. Widths of 8, 10, or 12 metres. Street frontages that seem to leave little room for...

Dark Mode Emails: How to Design for Visibility and Impact

Image by DC Studio on Freepik With dark mode rolling out on various devices and email service providers, the need for emails to render correctly and legibly is vital. Dark mode...

The Best Luxury Cars in 2021

The best luxury cars that you can look out for this year. You are probably looking for the most comfortable car this year. You go for these types of cars...

What Happens During a Rental Property Inspection?

The rental property inspection is one main factor that sometimes leaves tenants wondering a lot of things. Though it might occasionally feel like a scary procedure, it is a lot...

Effective Pest Control Solutions in Ballarat: What You Need to Know

Living in Ballarat means enjoying a beautiful regional lifestyle, but it also comes with its share of challenges—one of which is managing pests. From termites threatening your home’s structure to...

How Legal Representation Helps Solve Family Disputes

Family disputes can be some of the most challenging legal matters individuals face. Issues involving separation, parenting arrangements, property division, and family responsibilities often involve both legal complexities and emotional...

hacklink esim new zealandBetimgrandpashabet girişzlibraryz libraryjojobetcialis 20 mg fiyat