Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Australia’s anti-corruption commissioner has a trust problem. He needs to change course to fix it

  • Written by: William Partlett, Associate Professor of Public Law, The University of Melbourne

The commissioner of the National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC), Paul Brereton, is once again facing criticism for his handling of a potential conflict of interest.

On Tuesday in a Senate estimates hearing, NACC Chief Executive Philip Reed faced difficult questions about why the NACC commissioner did not fully disclose to parliament the extent of his ongoing relationship with the inspector-general of the Australian Defence Force (ADF).

This disclosure failure is far more than a small detail. It comes after a 2024 finding[1] by the NACC inspector that Brereton engaged in “officer misconduct” in relation to a conflict of interest concerning the Robodebt scandal.

This again brings into question the commissioner’s ability to effectively manage conflicts of interest and avoid the perception of bias. In particular, it shows the defensive strategy Brereton and his team have taken to responding to these types of questions is backfiring.

To repair trust in his leadership and ensure the effectiveness of the NACC, Brereton must change course and be far more transparent and proactive.

Off to a bad start

In 2023, the Robodebt Royal Commission referred six officials involved in the scandal to the NACC for determinations of whether they engaged in “corrupt conduct”.

Prior to making this determination, Brereton publicly declared a conflict of interest on these referrals and stated he would remove himself from the decision-making process.

In June 2024, the NACC announced it would not be investigating[2] the six officials.

Read more: The National Anti-Corruption Commission turns 2 – has it restored integrity to federal government?[3]

After receiving hundreds of complaints about this decision, the inspector of the NACC – the watchdog of the watchdog – published a report[4] finding the commissioner failed to fully remove himself from the decision-making process.

This failure, the report concluded, was “officer misconduct” because it could have led a reasonable person to think the decision not to investigate was biased.

From bad to worse

This year, members of parliament began to raise a new potential concern about the commissioner: the nature of his ongoing relationship with the ADF.

The precise details of this relationship are also important to public perception because of the large number of defence-related matters the NACC must consider.

In response to a range of formal questions from parliament, Brereton disclosed that he remained part of the ADF Reserve but had formally resigned his post at the Inspector General for the ADF.

In September, however, we learned this didn’t fully capture the nature of his continuing relationship with the ADF.

In particular, media reporting[5] found a much closer relationship, including that the commissioner was continuing to provide “critical” capability to the Inspector General in an informal capacity.

This ongoing relationship raises concerns not just because of the nature of the NACC’s work. It also raises the possibility the commissioner failed to reveal the whole truth to parliament.

The watchdog’s trust problem

More broadly, these matters raise concerns the commissioner doesn’t understand how to effectively build public trust in his leadership.

The NACC was established in 2022 to restore public trust in the exercise of public power. This trust is crucial to the ongoing health of Australian democracy.

To perform its important duties, the NACC commissioner must be broadly trusted.

On this issue, Brereton has some making up to do.

This is not just because of the Robodebt case. It’s also because concerns about his leadership are eroding overall trust in the NACC.

A grey-haired woman speaks into a small microphone
Inspector Gail Furness has received an unexpected amount of complaints about the NACC. Lukas Coch/AAP[6]

The inspector of the NACC, Gail Furness, testified to Senate estimates on Tuesday. She said she didn’t expect the sheer volume of complaints that she has received over the past two years. These included complaints about slow processing times.

She also said the number of “quite complex matters” was “increasing”. This included, Furness said, 55 complaints she had recently received concerning the commissioner’s “ongoing engagement” with defence.

Defend and deflect

To date, the commissioner and his team have adopted a defensive strategy to this trust problem. Their strategy includes downplaying or minimising these concerns.

In 2024, the NACC even included on its website[7] a page characterising some concerns as “misinformation”.

More recently, in response to the undisclosed relationship with the inspector general, Brereton simply stated:

any perceived or actual conflict of interest that arises is managed appropriately.

On Tuesday in Senate estimates, NACC CEO Philip Reed said:

if public confidence is being impacted, it’s not our work […] it’s actually the amount of negative material that emerges about us that we have virtually no means of addressing.

Building trust

The perceptions of bias at the root of this trust problem cannot be “managed appropriately”, downplayed or classified as misinformation. To really build trust, the NACC and its leadership team must fundamentally change course.

First, they must openly and fully acknowledge to the public anything that involves even a minor potential for a conflict of interest. A good start would be a public announcement that Brereton is severing all ties to the ADF.

Second, they must make it clear to the public how the commissioner is distancing himself from matters involving conflicts of interest. This must include far more details about how Brereton (or anyone else in the NACC leadership team) is being fully excluded from the decision-making process when a conflict of interest is declared.

It’s not too late for the NACC and its leadership team to regain public trust and perform the role they are paid to do: safeguard trust in public power.

The stakes are high. We need only look to the United States today to see the terrible consequences of low levels of trust in government.

Hopefully Brereton and his team will take this opportunity to change course.

References

  1. ^ 2024 finding (www.theguardian.com)
  2. ^ would not be investigating (www.theguardian.com)
  3. ^ The National Anti-Corruption Commission turns 2 – has it restored integrity to federal government? (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ published a report (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ media reporting (www.abc.net.au)
  6. ^ Lukas Coch/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  7. ^ on its website (www.nacc.gov.au)

Authors: William Partlett, Associate Professor of Public Law, The University of Melbourne

Read more https://theconversation.com/australias-anti-corruption-commissioner-has-a-trust-problem-he-needs-to-change-course-to-fix-it-266991

The Weekend Times Magazine

Northern New South Wales may be facing a schoolies invasion

Northern New South Wales may be facing a “schoolies invasion” and unit, apartment and townhouse owners need to prepare – or be left with a potentially large clean-up bill. ...

CHECK.CHECK.CHECK. The new ‘Slip, Slop, Slap,’ for a night out campaign

CHECK.CHECK.CHECK. The new ‘Slip, Slop, Slap,’ for a night out launched by the Night Time Industries Association A new campaign Check. Check. Check. encouraging punters to do their...

Airbnb bans party houses

PARTY HOUSE BAN BY AIRBNB WELCOMED BY STRATA SECTOR A decision by Airbnb to ban so called party houses has been applauded by the strata sector in New South Wales and...

Weekend Escapes Closer to Home: Making the Most of Every Litre

Rising fuel prices are changing more than household budgets—they are changing the way Australians holiday. For many families, a weekend away has traditionally meant filling the car and heading several hundred...

Discover the Benefits of Lifestyle Awnings for Your Home

Image by evening_tao on Freepik Adding shade and style to your outdoor space is easier than ever with Lifestyle Awnings. Whether you want to enjoy your backyard comfortably, protect your...

Defacto Partner Visa Help from Best Immigration Lawyer AU

When two people decide to share their lives together, the legal paperwork shouldn’t get in the way. But if your relationship involves immigration, it often does. Australia’s partner visa process...

Effective Pest Control Solutions in Ballarat: What You Need to Know

Living in Ballarat means enjoying a beautiful regional lifestyle, but it also comes with its share of challenges—one of which is managing pests. From termites threatening your home’s structure to...

5 Things You Must Do in Australia

If you are setting sights on Australia as your next holiday destination this year, then you are about to embark on a life-changing adventure. The country offers an exciting and...

What is Medicines Optimisation and Why is it Important?

Medicines optimisation is a patient-focused approach to safe and effective medication use that helps people get the best possible outcomes from their treatments. Rather than simply ensuring patients take their...

hacklink Betimgüvenilir bahis sitelerizlibraryz libraryjojobet