Google AI

Weekend Times


The Times

Business News

Report on social media age assurance trial says there is not a one-size-fits-all solution

  • Written by: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

The government’s trial has found age-assurance for its under-16 social media ban can be done effectively and protect privacy but there is not a one-size-fits-all model.

The report, from an independent company and released in full, also warns continued vigilance is needed on privacy and other issues.

It found some providers, in the absence of guidance, were collecting too much data, over-anticipating what regulators would require.

The ban on under 16s having their own social media accounts has been passed by parliament and comes into effect in December. It covers a wide range of platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X, and YouTube (which was recently added).

The measure is world-leading, and has been very controversial. One issue has been the degree of likely reliability of age verification.

The trial looked at various age assurance methods including AI, facial analysis, parental consent and identity documents. The methods were judged on accuracy, usability and privacy grounds.

More than 60 technologies were examined from 48 age assurance vendors.

The report concluded age assurance systems “can be private, robust and effective”. Moreover there was “a plethora” of choices available for providers, and no substantial technological limitations.

“But we did not find a single ubiquitous solution that would suit all use cases, nor did we find solutions that were guaranteed to be effective in all deployments.” Instead, there was “a rich and rapidly evolving range of services which can be tailored and effective depending on each specified context of use”.

The age assurance service sector was “vibrant, creative and innovative”, according to the report, with “a pipeline of new technologies”.

It had a robust understanding of the handling of personal information and a strong commitment to privacy.

But the trial found opportunities for technological improvements, including ease of use.

On parental control systems, the trial found these could be effective.

“But they serve different purposes. Parental control systems are pre-configured and ongoing but they may fail to adapt to the evolving capacities of children including potential risks to their digital privacy as they grow and mature, particularly through adolescence.

"Parental consent mechanisms prompt active engagement between children and their parents at key decision points, potentially supporting informed access.”

The trial found while the assurance systems were generally secure, the rapidly evolving threat environment meant they could not be considered infallible.

They needed continual monitoring, improvement and attention to compliance with privacy requirements.

Also, “We found some concerning evidence that in the absence of specific guidance, service providers were apparently over-anticipating the eventual needs of regulators about providing personal information for future investigations.

"Some providers were found to be building tools to enable regulators, law enforcement or Coroners to retrace the actions taken by individuals to verify their age which could lead to increased risk of privacy breaches, due to unnecessary and disproportionate collection and retention of data.”

Communications Minister Anika Wells said: “While there’s no one-size-fits-all solution to age assurance, this trial shows there are many effective options and importantly that user privacy can be safeguarded”.

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more https://theconversation.com/report-on-social-media-age-assurance-trial-says-there-is-not-a-one-size-fits-all-solution-263909

The Weekend Times Magazine

Vacancies increase sharply in outer Sydney, as inner-city suburbs ease

The REINSW Vacancy Rate Survey results for July 2020 show that COVID-19 continues to impact the residential rental market. Vacancies in Sydney overall increased for the fifth successive month and now...

Understanding Root Canal Treatment – What You Need to Know

For many people, hearing the term root canal treatment brings immediate anxiety. It’s one of the most feared dental procedures, often associated with pain and discomfort. However, this perception is outdated...

Why Pigmentation Removal Melbourne Treatments Help Restore Even Skin Tone

Skin pigmentation concerns are common among individuals of all ages. Dark spots, uneven skin tone, and sun damage can affect the appearance of the skin and often develop due to...

Tips for Choosing a Caravan for Australian Conditions

Australia's landscapes are unlike anywhere else in the world. From scorching outback heat and corrugated dirt tracks to coastal humidity and alpine cold, the demands placed on a caravan can...

Creating Dream Backyards with Professional Pool Builders Sydney

In a city like Sydney, where outdoor living is central to daily life, having a well-designed pool can transform a property into a private retreat. This is why homeowners turn...

Why Car Sharing is dominating Car Renting

Sustainability, budget, urban living, lack of parking – these are just a few of the reasons that many people are choosing not to buy cars in today’s environment. ...

Making the most of a short Singapore stopover

A Singapore stopover can disappear into airport transfers, hotel check-in and a long list of places that looked close together on a map. With one or two nights available, the...

House Builders in Melbourne Delivering Homes Built for Modern Living

Choosing the right house builders Melbourne is one of the most important steps in creating a home that feels comfortable, functional, and built to last. House builders play a central role...

Mining Hose for Dewatering and Water Transfer Applications

Dewatering systems need to move water efficiently while equipment and hoses may be relocated as site conditions change. The mining hose should be selected around the actual duty and conveyed material...

hacklink Betimgrandpashabet giriszlibraryz libraryjojobet